In
a topic-driven, well-developed paragraph, SUMMARIZE Warren’s argument. Clearly
identify the authors’ thesis (main argument) and supporting arguments. Be
specific. Use examples from the text in your response.
NOTE: After posting on the blog, open up the CANVAS assignment (by the same name) and DO copy and paste the URL address into the CANVAS "WEB URL" text box so that I have record of your submission on Canvas. Thanks.
Warrens summary was about her at Vanderbilt dealing with Christianity and a bit of identity. At the beginning of the article, she opens up and says exactly who she was and what she believes in. She begins to work at Vanderbilt university and struggles with their policy of the behavior of a true Christian. Vanderbilt didn't believe that she was a Christian because of her behavior and so she got kicked out and faced major Impasse. At the beginning she did say that she liked alcohol and that's not a healthy Christian routine to follow.
ReplyDeleteTish Warren speaks of an issue that is very present in today's pop culture. She tells of her experience as a Christian at Vanderbilt University where she was a leader of a religious organization on campus. When her group started being the "wrong kind of Christians" they were kicked off of campus. In 2011, the organization was given the chance to drop their doctrinal and purpose statement because the year before a guy in a frat was "ousted" for being gay. Therefore, Vanderbilt made it a policy and forbade belief standards for any campus organization. Warren goes into some small detail of the process she went through to find common ground. As a result of her efforts, the policy did not change, and the group she had lead for two years ended up losing their registration as a campus group. However, the organization still flourishes on the campus. They reach out to the students because they have developed the "craft of being both bold and irenic, truthful and humble." Warren thought that an attractive faith would get people on board, however when belief standards take their place it seems to be the opposite.
ReplyDeleteThe Wrong Kind of Christian- summary
ReplyDeleteThis essay is basically Warren sating that in Vanderbilt and other universities are denying people to be in Christian groups at school just because they are the “wrong kind of Christian.” She goes on by saying “Increasingly, orthodox beliefs and practices are forbidden as those in power forfeit a robust understanding of religious pluralism,” which means that Christian beliefs are being band more and more because people miss using what it means to be a true Christian. Her organization was kicked out of Vanderbilt because they weren’t what they wanted them to be. Because she made a stand for what she believed her organization was cut but, she still went out and tried to make her point and made t-shirts to let other people know about what it is they stand for. She points out that there are people who are being beaten and killed because they are Christians and that we should not be afraid of being who we are. Warren made it very clear of the issue going on around the world and in schools that we should stick to our faith no madder what.
In her essay, Warren explains her experience at
ReplyDeleteVanderbilt University. She was in a group on campus that was all Christian. Her group was criticized for being discriminatory because of their beliefs. Then the group was forced to not meet on campus anymore because the university did not want discrimination on their campus. It ended up that her group was discriminated against because of their beliefs. The group then made t-shirts that said, "WE ARE HERE," and still exists today.
Tish Harrison Warren in her article, “The Wrong Kind of Christian” explains how religious groups at Vanderbilt University are being banned and although the administration said that religious groups were allowed on campus they couldn't practice what they actually believed. Warren explains this problem as an “impasse” where there was no progress available. The university was afraid that the “religious beliefs” of the groups would be too exclusive and that students would not feel as accepted by these groups. This started when a Christian fraternity kicked out multiple people because they violated their behavioral policy and on of those people claimed he was kicked out because he was “gay”. Because of this the administration started cracking down on all religious groups saying that any one should be allowed into the leadership and they cant make them affirm their doctrinal views. Basically anyone could be a leader and didn't have to affirm that they actually believed what the Bible says. Warren explains it as, “being the wrong Christians” and even though tried everything, silent protesting, and praying in front of the administration building they couldn't get the administration to move on their judgement. The students still meet and even though they cant meet on campus or claim the Vanderbilt name they hand t-shirts that say “WE ARE HERE”. The gospel of Jesus is still moving on that campus.
ReplyDeleteTish Harrison wrote an article about 'The Wrong Kind of Christian'. She spoke about being a Christian was really hard in a urban setting and attending church was also a struggle for her as well. It was also hard for to join a Christian fraternity because she knew of a couple students are got kicked out of school due to the fact that are living a gay lifestyle. She had to change to be a part of the fraternity. Another thing is that she that she took part in groups in Vanderbilt University.
ReplyDeleteIn a Christianity Today article titled The Wrong Kind of Christian, author Tish Warren tells the story of how a student organization she worked for got kicked off of the Vanderbilt college campus. The group she had help lead for two years, Graduate Christian Fellowship, allowed anyone to join, however student leaders were required to affirm their religious doctrine and purpose statement. Vanderbilt told the group they must remove that policy or they would lose their status as a registered student organization. There was a line between good and evil, and the university saw that the group fell on the evil side because of two issues: sexual expression and creedal belief. The university viewed the group as not only bad, but evil due to their set truths on sexual autonomy. After over a year of battling the university, fourteen religious groups lost their organizational status. This is happening at other universities all around the nation. To move forward we must “resist bitterness, cynicism, or retaliation, demonizing the university or the culture.” (Warren 3) There must be forgiveness and repentance, and overall we should not be surprised by the rejection. Christians all over the world are facing rejection, brutality, and even death. As Christians we must hold strong in our faith, and carry on with compassion and courage.
ReplyDeleteIn The Wrong Kind of Christian Tish Warren talks about her struggles at Vanderbilt. It started with her group being on probation. She says they “had to drop the requirement that student leaders affirm our doctrinal and purpose statement.” If they did not do this their end result would be losing their status as a student registered organization. Next a student got kicked out of a group because he was gay. Vanderbilt put a stop to this by forbidding any belief standards for those wanting to join or lead any campus group. Vanderbilt was trying not to offend anybody. It got to the point where no religious organizations were allowed unless they were easily changeable. Vanderbilt thought of Christians as a threat for some reason. There was a fine line between what Vanderbilt allowed and what they didn’t allow. Most Christians fell on the wrong side of the line. Everything that is going on at Vanderbilt goes on at all kind of different universities. “We need not be afraid; the Gospel is as unstoppable as it is unacceptable.” This should encourage Christians at all universities to keep pressing on no matter how a college treats them.
ReplyDeleteThroughout the article, Warren tells us of her time at Vanderbilt. She was in an all Christian group that was talked bad about for discrimination. The group was disbanded by the University to keep discrimination down. She then explains how the group was discriminated against.
ReplyDeleteIn Tish Warren’s essay “The Wrong Kind of Christian“, she mainly explains how believing in Christ cannot be accepted by a religious institution, called the Vanderbilt University. Thereby she tells the story out of her own opinion and experience. Everything started with outing of one student being gay. Her religious group, “InterVarsity”, “welcomes anyone as a member”. But to be part of you have to sign its “doctrinal statement”. With the time, the University began to introduce “new policies” which “privileged certain groups and forbade all others”. Results are listed in her essay. She had to leave the campus and University and moved away, “no happy ending”. These things are as well happening on other universities, because “orthodox beliefs and practices are forbidden as those in power forfeit a robust understanding of religious pluralism.” The student organization is banned from the school, but people organized themselves with T-shirts with the phrase, “We are here”.
ReplyDeleteWarrens article is about her experience at Vanderbilt University. She was a part of an all Christian group that was viewed negatively due to their poor reputation. One student was kicked out of the group for being gay, so the university stepped in and banned any belief standards for those wanting to join or lead groups on campus.For some reason Vanderbilt viewed christianity as a threat.
ReplyDeleteWarren's article is about her troubling times at Vanderbilt University. She says that it started when on person got kicked out of the group for being gay, after that the university put an end to thereby making a rule saying that you cannot not kick anyone out for joining or leading religious groups. Christian people need to carry on compassion and not judge anyone for their beliefs.
ReplyDeleteIn the article "The Wrong Kind of Christian" written by Tish Harrison Warren explains how most places are too sensitive to the thought of homosexuals in the presence of religion. Tish talks about her time working at Vanderbilt University forming youth groups and mission trips. Although the school kicked her off campus due to other students differences, "One student said he was ousted because he is gay. Vanderbilt responded by forbidding any belief standards for those wanting to join or lead any campus groups." Warren also claims at the beginning of the article that she was comfortable around non-believers the most because she said she relates to them the most with "truthful, spiritual, and moral" standards. Vanderbilt phrases Tish as 'The Wrong Type of Christian' due to the differences in others. Vandy seems to believe that when sexual sin and Christianity is put in the same area, Christianity will lose due to homosexuality being so opened and sensitive.
ReplyDeleteIn this essay Tish Harrison Warren the former leader of the Graduate Christian fellowship group at the University of Vanderbilt, explains the Universities harsh and ruthless terms to the religious groups on campus. Warren tells us the story of how she is a christian and is loving caring loves to reason and debate about things. As the essay progresses she goes on to tell us how The university of Vanderbilt was closing the doors of some religious groups around campus, due to the fact of the discrimination of other as in gay lesbian or any one that did not stand for the groups beliefs. Warren took measure in her own hands they had protest with in reason shared with the university the groups intentions and made clear that no one is discriminated from there group. The university would have nothing to do with it if any professor would make a post or comment on the mater the university threatened their job in closing nothing seemed to get better for Warren so her and her husband packed up and moved to a different college.
ReplyDeleteTish Warren's article 'The Wrong Kind of Christian" first talks about Vaderbilt's experience when a fraternity excludes someone for being a homosexual. She talked about how they made a new policy saying that no one could be "excluded from a leadership post on ideological grounds." But it doesn't talk about sexual activity or identity, therefore homosexuals can still be dismissed. And Ms. Warren says that more universities are becoming like Vanderbilt. "Increasingly, orthodox beliefs and practices are forbidden."
ReplyDelete